Books like Pen Pal

If you loved Pen Pal by J.T. Geissinger, here are 10 books you might enjoy next! If you don’t find what you’re looking for, check out my romance book database where you can search by your dream trope combinations.

Please note as an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

1
Love & Other Killers Brynne Weaver
1 shared tropes
Dark Serial killer
2
Everything We Never Said Sloan Harlow
400 pages Standalone Published by Wednesday Books 1 shared tropes
Dark
3
King of Pride Ana Huang
400 pages Book 2 of the Kings of Sin Series Self-published 1 shared tropes
Dark Forbidden romance Billionaire
4
King of Sloth Ana Huang
528 pages Book 4 of the Kings of Sin Series Self-published 1 shared tropes
Dark Enemies to lovers Forced proximity Billionaire
5
If There's a Way Jessie Walker
428 pages Book 2 of the Lost Boys Self-published 1 shared tropes
Dark Second chance Friends to lovers Found family
6
Burning Daylight Emily McIntire
400 pages Standalone Self-published 1 shared tropes
Dark Forbidden romance Retellings
7
Capri 3 Jahquel J.
200 pages Novella Self-published 1 shared tropes
Dark Friends to lovers African american
8
City of Smoke and Brimstone Kayla Edwards
480 pages Book 1 of House of Devils Series Self-published 1 shared tropes
Dark Vampires Witches
9
King of Envy Ana Huang
416 pages Book 5 of the Kings of Sin Series Self-published 1 shared tropes
Dark Forced proximity Billionaire
10
Hateful Games Simran .
380 pages Standalone Self-published 1 shared tropes
Dark Enemies to lovers Forced proximity Marriage of convenience