Books like The First Witch of Boston

If you loved The First Witch of Boston by Andrea Catalano, here are 10 books you might enjoy next! If you don’t find what you’re looking for, check out my romance book database where you can search by your dream trope combinations.

Please note as an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

1
Small Town, Big Magic Hazel Beck
384 pages Book 1 of Witchlore Series Published by Berkley 2 shared tropes
Halloween Witches Magic
2
The Unfortunate Side Effects of Heartbreak and Magic Breanne Randall
384 pages Standalone Published by Berkley 2 shared tropes
Halloween Witches Cozy Magic
3
City of Smoke and Brimstone Kayla Edwards
480 pages Book 1 of House of Devils Series Self-published 1 shared tropes
Witches Dark Vampires
4
The Marionettes Katie Wismer
380 pages Standalone Self-published 1 shared tropes
Witches Magic Vampires
5
The Crescent Moon Tearoom Stacy Sivinski
336 pages Standalone Published by Berkley 1 shared tropes
Witches Cozy Magic
6
Violet Made of Thorns Gina Chen
400 pages Book 1 of Violet Made of Thorns Series Published by Delacorte Press 1 shared tropes
Witches Enemies to lovers Retellings Magic
7
Salem's Fall Rektok Ross
420 pages Standalone Published by Sourcebooks Fire 1 shared tropes
Halloween Dark
8
Best Hex Ever Nadia El-Fassi
352 pages Standalone Published by Berkley 1 shared tropes
Witches Magic
9
Queen of Chaos Amelia Hutchins
450 pages Book 1 of Vegas Immortals Series Self-published 1 shared tropes
Witches Enemies to lovers Dark Magic
10
Spicy Little Curses J.T. Geissinger
384 pages Standalone Self-published 1 shared tropes
Halloween