Books like Make My Wish Come True

If you loved Make My Wish Come True by Rachael Lippincott, here are 10 books you might enjoy next! If you don’t find what you’re looking for, check out my romance book database where you can search by your dream trope combinations.

Please note as an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

1
The Christmas Swap Talia Samuels
320 pages Standalone Self-published 5 shared tropes
Christmas Holiday Lesbian Lgbt
2
Make the Season Bright Ashley Herring Blake
320 pages Standalone Published by Berkley 5 shared tropes
Christmas Holiday Lesbian Lgbt
3
You're a Mean One, Matthew Prince Timothy Janovsky
336 pages Standalone Published by Sourcebooks Casablanca 4 shared tropes
Christmas Holiday Lgbt Queer
4
Bookshops & Bonedust Travis Baldree
352 pages Book 2 of the Legends & Lattes Series Published by Tor 3 shared tropes
Lesbian Lgbt Queer Cozy
5
A Pirate's Life for Tea Rebecca Thorne
400 pages Book 1 of Tomes & Tea Series Self-published 3 shared tropes
Lesbian Lgbt Queer Pirates
6
Girl, Serpent, Thorn Melissa Bashardoust
336 pages Standalone Published by Flatiron Books 3 shared tropes
Lesbian Lgbt Queer Retellings
7
Delilah Green Doesn't Care Ashley Herring Blake
368 pages Book 1 of Bright Falls Series Published by Berkley 3 shared tropes
Lesbian Lgbt Queer Gay
8
The Mermaid, the Witch, and the Sea Maggie Tokuda-Hall
384 pages Standalone Published by Candlewick 3 shared tropes
Lesbian Lgbt Queer Pirates
9
Chef's Kiss T.J. Alexander
320 pages Standalone Published by Berkley 3 shared tropes
Lesbian Lgbt Queer
10
We Do What We Do in the Dark Michelle Hart
240 pages Standalone Published by Riverhead Books 3 shared tropes
Lesbian Lgbt Queer Gay